I know that
Malach doesn't like
NL ball, but that is because he's an uneducated fool. I, for one, love
NL ball. I hate the DH, I think it's bad for the game. It's part of an overall problem with the game, an emphasis on
homeruns instead of hitting.
What I like about the
NL is that you still get to see bunts. There is nothing better, in my mind, than a well-executed bunt. In the AL, you almost never get to see a bunt. Why? Too much emphasis on swinging for the fences. While seeing a pitcher bat may be boring to some,
Zambrano is one of the best hitters in the league. If he moved to the outfield, he'd hit forty a season easy (he pinch-hits fairly often). He'd probably hit .300, too. I know that most hitters stink, but I blame the managers. If the managers would make pitchers spend more time hitting, you'd see better hitting from the nine spot, like you did with the Braves in the 90s;
Maddux,
Glavine, and
Smoltz were all very, very good hitters.
Another thing I like about not having the DH is that teams steal bases. I love base-stealing, there's a lot to it. There are
pickoffs, attempts by the 1B to hold the runner, and there is timing. It's a fun battle to watch that is, with few exceptions, almost entirely restrained to the
NL (unless Rickey Henderson is on a team). The
BoSox this year are a true exception to the "big ball" of the AL as they are playing a more
NL "small ball" style, but have a good enough lineup to mix both styles and still hit for power.
I also don't like how the AL keeps incomplete ball players, guys who don't respect all parts of the game, around. Man, I tell you, you couldn't keep a lot of the old-timers off the field. No sir, they would demand to be out there. Why? Because that's part of the game. Sitting on your ass for nine innings and
occasionally getting up to hit just isn't baseball. If you can't play a position, then maybe you don't belong in baseball. But I know the game changes and that this is my weakest argument, which is why I buried it in the post.
Finally, the DH has caused too many AL pitchers to head-hunt. Guys like Clemens and Pedro are the best examples. But when they got to the
NL and had to face retaliation, they didn't throw at heads. It keeps the pitchers honest, it keeps the game fair. Pitchers don't get to take it easy and act tough when they aren't tough and are afraid to face retaliation. In the
NL, they know that if they throw at someone, they will have to face the consequences, and that's why they don't as often in the
NL.
It's a great style of play.